This Noho bakery is best known for their elaborately decorated sugar cookies, but their crispy-mallow crunch cookie is what we’ll be coming back for. It’s a sweet, sticky, caramel-y affair. The cookie is large, flat, and flexible—the antithesis of their chocolate chip cookie, which is like a softball of thick, chip-studded dough. If you like extremely thick chocolate chip cookies, you’ll probably like that one, too. And those sugar cookies that look like famous people? Also pretty delicious.