I a basic Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jelly Sandwich (I even like Uncrustables) BUUUUT this little shop in Milwaukee is a GAME CHANGER! Fresh made Amish Peanut Butter, Jelly & Jams....I can't contain m

So this was my second time at the peanut butter and jelly deli. This time I opted for the grilled cheese and jelly, I chose the cheddar with cherry jalapeño jam grilled on the Panini. It was so so goo

Such a unique idea and so many different options. They also have a lot of peanut butter options and jam options for sale and I can confirm that they are also delicious. Cozy and informal to eat inside