Run by a local family (kids included), NYPD is the go-to for famished students after a night of vodka cranberry pitchers at Skeeps. A line out the door lasts from 11pm until close at 3am, but that doesn’t slow down service—the hustlers behind the counter are constantly bouncing between taking orders, pulling pies out of the oven, and cleaning the single-stall bathroom. If pizza alone doesn’t seal the deal, there are also garlic knots, plus red velvet cake, to round out the night.