Get up early, and take the ferry over to Chappaquiddick for an adventure, which should include stopping at the Mytoi Japanese Garden to feel one with nature and have some pond time. When you’re done, Atlantic Fish and Chop House is waiting for you in Edgartown with waterfront seating and harbor views. It’s not super stuffy, but the energy is resort casual—think heavy on the loafers and linen—and you’ll have a slew of great options for seafood and whole fish. Order the branzino if it’s available and get the charbroiled oysters to congratulate yourself for booking this vacation. For that friend who doesn’t like seafood, they also have great steaks.