The pizza had a burn taste to it. If you're into charcoal taste pizza then this is your place. It's on Madison Avenue

An unexpected gem in horrible weather! We were stuck on the Merritt Parkway on Friday during the snowstorm and needed to get off to eat and rest. Found Goodfellas Pizzeria and was pleasantly surprised

I've had way better pizza than Goodfellas. The sauce wasn't good. Taste more garlic and bread I won't be back