I'm still thinking about this pizza! It was so good, the only downside is that it's a bit pricey per slice. But the place itself is really nice for hangouts as they open till 11-12 depending on the we

First time to NY Pie and it was amazing! Thin pizza with a perfectly crispy undercarriage. Staff were super friendly and helpful. Will be back!

New ownership, great pizza. Don't judge this place by old reviews -- the quality is night and day. Gave New York Pie another chance and it paid off. One of the best in Santa Rosa.