The inn possesses a retro charm. The room was clean, comfortable, and secure. Due to its robust construction, it's very quiet inside the room. I enjoyed some time out in the well-kept courtyard. It is

Beautiful place, but they stole my collectible quarters…. I would still go back though. Staff is nice and the police also could’ve stolen my quarters.

On Sept 21, 2025, I checked in at The Bay Inn and was immediately confronted by the manager after showing my Brooklyn, NY ID. Within minutes, he became aggressive, yelling “You’re in the wrong state”