This corner neighborhood shop does it all: pizza, hoagies, strombolis, oven-baked pastas, and shareable mains like veal piccata. This makes it a solid choice for everything from a platonic catch up with an old friend to an essential takeout option when you’re hosting game night. Between the wood booth seating and the long tavern-style bar, everything inside feels super old-fashioned. And from their menu—which is as long as a mini novel—to the excellent service, it’s a place that demonstrates what makes a throwback spot a classic.