Pink Pony was poppin' when we visited in October, at the end of the tourist season. It felt like everyone on the island was at the restaurant, but amazingly, we were seated relatively quickly and were

Pretty solid food. Immensely popular, especially after the release of the Pink Pony Club song. The best place to sit is on the deck that overlooks the harbor. Some of the seating is in the back of the

The outdoor view is the seller! Service was excellent. They charged extra for my big ice cube in my Old Fashioned...SMH! On the island foodwise generally speaking, repeat customers are not important.