Countless times I've come and they been closed early 30-hour before closing time kinda a major inconvenience when driving from highland to new paltz just to turn around because it's closed

Supposed to be open 7:30 am every day. Stopped by 9 am on a Saturday it it was closed. No update to the schedule was on the window. So I suggest you call before you go to make sure they are open.

Come on folks! You're in New York with MILLIONS of NY style delis and you're considering Subway's portioned/weighed out, turkey based, processed crap?! Go to a deli. ANY deli!