Found this place on door dash, and then realized they are pretty popular! The door dash and uber eats app options are slightly disappointing, no option to add toppings to the heart shaped pizza. Also

Grandma pie is the best and should be eaten piping hot to bring out the flavor. I reheat before eating if I order it takeout. Family owned business and they all come to greet you when you pick up your

Amore Pizza absolutely hit the spot! The slice I ordered was massive (big enough to share with my honey). In my opinion, it's honestly one of the biggest and best in Nutley. The crust was perfectly cr