Welcome to Key West, where every man, woman, child, and rooster claims to make the best or most unique version of key lime pie. This is a good problem to have, but they can’t all be telling the truth. So if you’re going to prioritize just one key lime pie spot, make it the one from Kermit’s. This place is a Key West classic that makes a very delicious (and unique) chocolate-dipped version on a popsicle stick. It’s a manageable size, easy to eat while walking around, and overall a pitch-perfect slice of key lime pie. There’s some cute garden seating in the back too in case you don’t want to eat this on the run.