Update: 2/28/25 - Went back after a year to give them another chance. We were hoping to not see the previous manager and similar situations etc. Immediately upon arrival we noticed the place was empty

It's my new go-to destination!!! We just made the move here and I'm ecstatic that we stumbled upon this gem. These bagels are reminiscent of the authentic NY/NJ bagels that I grew up with. Cayman was

There were flys and the bagels and the worker maybe would noticed if they weren't cuddling at the cash register