For anyone hoping for a swanky meal in a converted church, The Preacher’s Son has heard your prayers—stained glass windows and all. This place has the kind of wine list that would impress fussy clients, as well as good New American food and truly excellent desserts (hello, lemon ice cream and coffee swiss rolls). After your meal, head to the downstairs speakeasy bar, The Undercroft, especially if it’s a Tuesday or Thursday, which is when they have live jazz.